Help Wanted:
Needing a Guide for Finding Iris Dement's Voice
I expected more? Too much? Something different? Whatever it was, my expectation didn’t match what I heard in Iris Dement’s performance at the Stoughton Opera House in Wisconsin. Her song selection—originals and covers—is incredibly rich as it walks through realms of past and present, faith and doubt. As far as where her songs lead, she is definitely challenging a listener with equal parts hymnic Gospel and universalist ponderings.
For me as a Christian trying to allow this philosophy to inform my view of the world, the experience became like the challenge of reading Brian McLaren’s A New Kind of Christian—a postmodern, less-concerned-about-truth approach to the Truth of Jesus. I don’t know that I was up to such a challenge that night, although it was fitting that it occurred during the season of Lent, a time of meditation and contemplation.
Whether or not I was up to the spiritual challenge, I clearly wasn’t up to the musical challenge. Dement’s voice doesn’t country warble as much as stays invariably in the same whine. I know many people really appreciate Dement, the small amount of recordings I’ve heard are nice, but that night, it all failed to capture me. It may take Dement fans to explain it to me—which is okay. Challenging walks—spiritual and musical—often require guides.
If you’re up to the task of guiding, please email me.
Pre-Show Thoughts
They’re in small cities and mid-size towns everywhere—arts series which bring an eclectic season of shows to communities, tapping into Boomer and older nostalgia while periodically gracing them with current gems. It always creates an odd atmosphere of audience members—equal parts season ticket holder and single show attendees. Showing up for a current gem means sitting next to season ticket holders who are here but do not know anything about the performer. They are prepared to be informed but perhaps not thoroughly engrossed; they’re amused and befuddled at the same time with a slight wish that the series director would book Manhattan Transfer more often.
That’s the rockist talking—that rock music snob which is mildly-to-severely offended by ignorance concerning all things in rock, blues, and folk music. The rockist is amused this evening to receive a program at a folk show which I read as if it is a Playbill.
Lest I become too conceited in these moments before the house lights go out, maybe it’s best to remember that friends of the St. Louis Symphony Orchestra probably had a similar disdain for me when I only showed up for Wynton Marsalis and the Lincoln Center Jazz Orchestra performance of his 1994 piece, Blood on the Fields. Those symphony supporters knew much more about what they were seeing than I did. They knew what it meant to be in Powell Hall. My lack of understanding was probably very apparent, although I was thoroughly enthralled by the music. It met a rock fan on a common ground.
Perhaps that’s where we find Iris Dement tonight. . .a common ground for people who else while hear Branson artists, barbershop quartets, and the Glenn Miller Orchestra. Besides, she packed the Stoughton Opera House, built in 1901, and restored down to its hard-backed, wooden seats with top hat racks beneath. It’s a gem of a room enlivening the main street of their small city outside of Madison, a main street trying to hold onto its charm as a way to retain a drawing forces for tourists and daytravelers.
Iris Dement
Stoughton Opera House







